Thursday, September 14, 2017

To Long, Don't Read (or) Yeah, You Ain't Getting Outta This One

If you've been to this blog before (and not been scared off), thanks.  If you're new and yesterday's doorstopper makes you question my sanity (and perhaps your's) that's okay.  I try not to write anything that could elicit a "tl;dr" comment.

But for when I do, if you're here reading then that comment is not necessary.  Clearly you're here to read what I write, which makes me wonder if Stockholm syndrome is in effect.  Not that you have to read any of this, or comment whether you do or do not read.  This is just me, writing my thoughts out loud.

Also, by all means comment.  Though, DAR, unless you come up with something more clever (or ambitious but rubbish), I may just keep ignoring them.

In other news, if you tune into 95.7 FM out of Lincoln NE on Sept. 23 at 7 am, you'll get to hear part of a story I wrote.  You can find them online here.  Lots of good stuff there.

Trying to crack into the lectionary, write a study/devotion/lesson based on the readings for the upcoming week.  Why?  Practice, and give me something to work on.  Got a few other things I've been wanting to dabble in.  Things along the lines of "Hmm... the current infatuation with science as the only answer sounds way to similar to when France tried to worship reason as a goddess.  I wonder how best to counter that."

Other than that, its just me here, being me and writing whatever tickles my fancy.

Wednesday, September 13, 2017

Lies, Darned Lies, and Statistics (or) I Think I Over Thought This One, But I'm Too Far To Stop Now

Yeah, this one's kinda long.  Sometimes having access to a blog is a dangerous thing.  So, if you like tangental discussions of aircraft, military history, and Star Wars, stick around.  Otherwise, maybe I'll be back tomorrow with something "normal."

Well, normal for me, at least.

There are a few things that I like that have no real usage in the profession I seek.  I am a fan of Star Wars. ("oh really?" you snark say)  I like World War 2 aircraft (well, actually, any aircraft, but 1939-45 had a lot of great planes).

What?  You're surprised I'm a nerd?  Clearly you've not been paying attention if this comes as a shock.

Anyway, being a nerd, I enjoy kibitzing the discussion regarding the ships of SW, and the aircraft from whenever.  So I was happy to have found a number of people on the interwebs who make videos about such things.  One is EckhartsLadder, who compares sci fi ships, most notably Star Wars.

What EL does is a "who would win" scenario, comparing two craft in "firepower," "defenses," and "intangibles" in a 1v1 with equal skilled pilots without mods or backup.  Best out of 10 wins.

The one that caught my attention was the Incom T-65 X-Wing vs. Incom/Subpro ARC-170. (here if you are interested)

Before I say anything else, I think if fair to say his method is flawed and shortsighted, but not a bad start.  Why?  Eric "Winkle" Brown and the Wildcat.

(insert Tim "the Toolman" Taylor questioning grunt here)

Captain Eric Brown, Fleet Air Arm, served during WW2 as a pilot.  Most notably he served with N. 1426 Flight: the RAF enemy aircraft testing squadron.  This mean that Brown got the opportunity to fly a lot of types of aircraft.  487 types.

Let that sink in a moment.  487 types.  Not 487 aircraft, but aircraft types.  This is a record that will never be broken.  Especially if you count the individual marks, not just types.  For example: Brown flew 14 versions of the Spitfire during his career, yet the record only lists Spitfire once.

Brown also has the most carrier landings ever: 2,407, in 20 different types.  Including the first tricycle undercarriage and first jet.

And he was the only Allied pilot to ever fly the Me 163 Komet rocket interceptor.  You know, the one with the corrosive fuel that would melt pilots, and if the plane hit a bump during takeoff it might explode.

He was a fan of the de Havilland Hornet and the F-86E Sabre, thinking both to be exceptional aircraft and his favorite regarding their engines.

Because of this vast experience, Brown was able to quantify what made for a good fighter plane.  He came up with six characteristics that an effective fighter should have.  They were:
  1. Speed
  2. Rate of climb
  3. Firepower
  4. Armor protection
  5. Pilot visibility
  6. Maneuverability (though he would stress "don't dogfight")
Corky Meyer, test pilot for Grumman during WW2 and beyond, listed four missions any "best" fighter should be able to perform.  These were:
  1. Fighter vs. fighter
  2. Bomber escort
  3. Ground attack
  4. Photoreconnaissance
Add on "easy to fly" (200-flight hour pilots can handle it) and built in numbers above 10,000 for a long duration.  Now, Corky claimed the P-47 Thunderbolt was best in Europe, and the F6F Hellcat was tops in Pacific.

What does any of this have to do with Star Wars?  Well, unless you were asleep in history class, or are not a nerd (even a little), it will come as no surprise that Mr. Lucas used a lot of inspiration from WW2.  Hey, if you've got good material, use it.

So, the Incom T-65B X-Wing vs. the Incom/Subpro ARC-170... who would win?  The X-Wing.

How frequently?  About 90+%, assuming we have a trained pilot in the seat.

So, to break it down, the X-Wing meets Brown's criteria better than the ARC.  It has the speed, and climb, sufficient firepower and armor/shields, and maneuverability.  All it lacks is an advantage in visibility.  Based on Corky's mission lineup, the X-Win does it all.  Perhaps not as well as a dedicated craft, but it is a "swing role" fighter.

Usually "jack of all trades" don't come out on top frequently.  But, bear with me a second while I take and replace the Star Wars craft with their 1940s doppelgängers.  (This is where EL missed some important items in his 1v1.)

The X-Wing is comparable to the P-38 Lightning, while the ARC-170 is the P-61 Black Widow.

If you're still wondering who wins, just look at the to planes for a second.


the Lockheed P-38G Lightning


the Northrop P-61 Black Widow
Any questions?

Oh, still aren't sure.  Well, consider, one is a twin engine single seat interceptor, the other is a twin engine three place night fighter... that is the size of a medium bomber.

Now, I ain't knocking the P-61.  She was designed as a purpose build radar equipped night fighter.  Heavily armed with 4x 20 mm cannon and 4x .50 cal machine guns in a turret.  Powered by two R-2800s, and able to tote around 3 tons of bombs, she was a powerful plane.  Very agile for how big she was, too, thanks to Northrop's clever spoilers.  A little late to prove itself, but, that's not the point.

The Lightning's a bit of an oddball.  Designed as a heavily armed interceptor, found to have great range, respectable agility, decent armor, and ridiculer versatility.  Four .50 cal machine guns and a 20 mm cannon, backed by up to a ton of bombs.  And her twin V-1710s made her one of the fastest planes of the early portion of the war.

So, who wins in a dogfight?  Well, first is the need to acknowledge the caveat to Brown's 6th characteristic: don't dogfight.  Why are speed and climb first?  Because the pilot who has the altitude and speed picks when the fight starts, and when it ends.  Diving attacks trump spinning and loops.  See the work of the Flying Tigers, or Red 2's interception over Yavin.

We have this notion that fighters are all about dogfighting and that goes back to the "romantic" depictions of the Great War.  Watching men like Ball, Bishop, Barker, Guynemer, Voss, and Richthofen dueling in chivalric arial joust makes for great stories.  Its not the truth.  Check out Oswald Boelcke's dicta:
  1. Try to secure advantages before attacking. If possible keep the sun behind you.
  2. Always carry through an attack when you started it.
  3. Fire only at close range and only when your opponent is properly in your sights.
  4. Always keep your eye on your opponent and never let yourself be deceived by ruses.
  5. In any form of attack it is essential to assail your opponent from behind.
  6. If your opponent dives on you, do not try to evade his onslaught but fly to meet him.
  7. When over the enemy's line never forget your own line of retreat.
  8. (For the Squadron) Attack on principle in groups of four or six. When the fight breaks up into a series of single combats take care that several do not go for one opponent.
Reading through the dicta it is clear that altitude and speed, employed in a slashing attack, are better than trying to "mix it up" with classic dogfights.

Okay, so performance is kinda the keystone factor.  If the fighter doesn't have enough get-up-and-go winning won't be likely.  But what about the other factors?

Firepower is self-evident.  You can have all the speed in the world, but without enough punch, it doesn't matter.  The MiG-3 found that out the hard way.

Armor protection should be obvious as well.  You need a strong, rugged craft to ride into battle.  There are plenty of stories of American planes shrugging off lots of hits.  Robert S. Johnson's P-47 taking all the ammo from an FW 190 is a paramount example.  But if your ship has the heft to shrug it off, it had better have the power to move.  Hence the order.  The A-4 Skyhawk is a great case study in how to correctly build a fighter.  First, find the limits of your size and weight, then pick a powerful engine, finally don't exceed the limits.

Pilot visibility is one that is easily forgotten and taken for granted.  The Bf 109 had a narrow canopy that made turning your head difficult.  The F-4 Phantom had heavy frames that limited view, especially for the rear canopy.  The F-8 Crusader had a lot of stuff in the windscreen, which made landings especially "fun."  Having visibility is majorly important for pilots, especially combat pilots.  The one who sees the target first wins.  Modern technologies, like radar, IR, long-range cameras, all improve situational awareness.

Lastly, again, is maneuverability.  If having the ability to "zoom-boom" is top, then agility isn't important, right?  Not at all.

The agility then is for defense, avoiding an attack, as seen in #6 of Dicta Boelcke.

So then, back to the P-38/P-61 debate.  In a straight up 1v1, who wins?

Answer: the pilot who sees his opponent first and has the altitude to start a diving attack, most likely.  But lets be "fair" for the argument.  In an equal level fight, where they meet at the merge, who wins . The P-38.  All the time.

Why?  Size is not the P-61's friend, and all that firepower is useless if you can't get it pointed at the target.  At this point some table-top gamer will be like "aha, what about the turret?"

You mean the turret that didn't work in the initial marks?  The turret that was there primarily for bomber interception?  The turret that added weight and complexity which degraded performance?  The turret that was a throwback to the turret fighters of the early 40s (the Defiant, Roc) and the two seat fighters of WW1?

Yes, in WW1 many of the early attempts at building a working fighter resulted in a pilot flying the plane, and the main armaments being manned by a gunner.  Care to guess how well it worked?  Well enough that one of the best fighters of the war, the Bristol F2A, was shot down a lot when flown like a two seater.

You see, the idea of the turret guns was a symptom of not paying attention to reality.  This exemplified itself in the phrase "the bombers will always get through."  Who needs escorts when the bombers are literal flying fortresses, bristling with guns?  The 8th Air Force, that's who.

What does any of this have to do with the X-Wing/ARC-170?  A lot.  EL assumed, like many do, that the numbers can lead to the answer.  This is what has lead to the X-Wing table top game.  People think that if you have a quantifiable amount more of speed, or agility, or aggression, you can win.  Which is where EL's idea of "intangibles" makes sense.

So, who wins, the X-Wing or the ARC-170?  With exceptional pilots in both, the X-Wing.  With average pilots in both, the X-Wing.

Why?  Well, four cannon is more weight-of-fire than two, meaning greater chance of hitting the target.  While the ARC does have more torpedoes, not enough to make a difference in a dogfight.  In an attack mission, different story.  The ARC is the better attack bomber.  (And, by the way, torpedoes are guided in the SW universe.)  Better acceleration, and the ability to keep that speed means the X-Wing determines when, and where, the fight starts and ends.  The X-Wing's smaller size means its harder to see, therefore harder to evade.

Of course the swing-role fighter beats the high-performance attacker in a dogfight.

Yeah, this one kinda got away from me.

Saturday, September 9, 2017

Where Is God During Hurricane Season (or) Someone Flunked Bible Class

It doesn't surprise me.  Not any more.  Supposedly trained religious "teachers" making ridiculous statements backed up with a few verses out of context.  A wild canine wandering about a flock would be more subtle.

I'm not surprised at all.  But it does frustrate me to no end.

So to deal with said frustration (and others as well), I'm writing this, sort of in response to a very amateur attempt at using Scripture.  And to give me something to do to "stretch my legs," theologically.

For those of you new to this blog, you may be surprised that I'd label veteran bible-thumper Max as an "amateur," but that's the politest term I can use for someone who is twisting Scripture.

With all the hurricanes the US has endured in the last couple weeks, and will probably endure in the next couple, its no surprise he wrote this article.  At least he wasn't claiming that believers can control the weather.  (And, yes, people have claimed this.  Listen to the explanation and correction here.)  Anyway, back to Max's article.

"Hurricane Irma is coming.  Where is God?" (read it here if you want)

As soon as I saw the title, warning alarms were sounding and shields were up.  "Oh, great, here comes another attempt to sell 'I can do all things' bologna."

He starts off okay, by asking questions that are really understandable in these situations.

1) How can this be happening?
2) How should we respond?
3) Where is God?

Before I get to his answer, I'll give the quick, but correct, answers.

1) Weather patterns and seasons.  Though to be fair, the destructiveness of weather is an extension of the Fall, though that explanation is not a quick one, nor necessary for this specific discussion at the moment.
2) Pray, for forgiveness and in thanks to God for salvation.  Look for ways to provide aid, either in person or by assisting with sending relief to those who will need it once the storms pass.
3) He is God.  He is here, as He promised He would always be.

To begin answering these, Max decides, wisely, to quote the Bible, but his choice proves anything but wise.
Jesus said, “There will be signs in the sun, moon and stars. On the earth, nations will be in anguish and perplexity at the roaring and tossing of the sea.” (Lk. 21:25, NIV)
Now, it is true that this is what Luke 21:25 says.  But what this passage has to do with the current state of the American Gulf Coast is not what Max thinks.  So, we shall start by employing the Three Rules For Sound Biblical Exegesis.

Context.
Context.
Context.

What is the context of Luke 21?  If you guessed "end of the world" based on what vs. 25 said, you'd be given partial credit.  Jesus is, for a short portion, speaking of the end of the world.  But for most of it, He's speaking of the end of the age.

The astute among you will have noticed "those aren't exactly the same."  And that's true.  The "end of the age," which is what all the "wars, rumors of wars, etc" is all about is the destruction of the Temple in 70 AD.  The hint is "this generation will not pass away before all this has taken place (vs. 32)."

Remember, though, the disciples asked Jesus "Teacher, when will these things be, and what will be the sign when these things are about to take place? (vs. 7)"

That's two questions.  I already showed you the answer to the first (when will these things be).  For the second question, allow me to go to Mark 13, mostly because the answer He gives is more direct.  (Its the same conversation, but Mark gives a different perspective.  That's why we have four Gospels.)

“But concerning that day or that hour, no one knows, not even the angels in heaven, nor the Son, but only the Father.  Be on guard, keep awake.  For you do not know when the time will come. (Mk. 13:32-33)"

So, having Max here pull out a whole implied "this is a sign Jesus will be here soon" is a bit dishonest.  Not that he's technically wrong, since all trials and troubles are signs of sin, which is why Christ came and died and rose.

Max goes on to say:
Increasing frequency of natural calamities are like the birth pangs of pregnancy—indications of an impending delivery. Christians do not know when Christ will return, but we believe we will see “…the Son of Man coming in the cloud with great power and glory. When these things (natural disasters) begin to take place, stand up and lift up your heads, because your redemption is drawing near.” (Lk. 21:27-28, NIV)
Um... no.  You did that wrong, Max.  The "Son of Man coming in the cloud" is a reference to the Ascension, which is the linchpin to the end of the age of the Temple and the Sinai Covenant.  Christ is saying to lift up you heads so the disciples can look at the cross, because their "redemption is drawing near."

While Max does use Psalm 121 decently, he's far too hands off in his approach to a crisis.  While, yes, we shouldn't dwell on our troubles, to "wallow" in our sorrows, but we need to be active in moving forward in our lives.

However, that was not the lesson we should glean from Peter's Amazing Not Drowning Show.

Peter didn't volunteer to leave the boat.  None of them did.  Why would they.  Being on a small craft in the middle of a stereotypically stormy sea is frightening enough.  Seeing what must undeniably be a ghost was too much.  The only reason Peter gets kudos is because he was smart enough to know that where Jesus is would be the safest place, and if He said it was safe to come to Him, then it was.  As long as Peter focused on Christ, he was safe, both physically and spiritually.

Granted, Peter had Jesus Christ, the Incarnate Word, standing next to him, so physical danger was irrelevant.

The last three paragraphs of Max's "oh, no, there's a storm, but its okay, God's got a plan" are just wishy-washy.  Not wrong, but nothing overly helpful.  Especially since nowhere does he mention Christ and Him crucified.  Its almost as if Max isn't a Christian pastor...

Yes, God has a plan.  And that plan was, and is, and will be, Christ crucified.  That is what saves us from sin, death, and the power of the devil.  It is our salvation.  Our inheritance.  Our narrow way to eternity.

But what about the here and now?  What about those who suffer sickness, injury, persecution, famine, unjust government, war, storm, and so on?  Paul answers that:

As it is written, “For your sake we are being killed all the day long; we are regarded as sheep to be slaughtered.”  (Romans 8:36)

He's quoting Psalm 44 (vs. 22 specifically).  David is expressing how God has saved Israel, and how He punishes them as He sees fit.  But that does not stop David from pleading for divine aid.  And he knows it will come, even if it does not come now or in the manner David asked for it.  Because unlike most contemporary Christians, David knew where his hope was anchored.  A hope Paul alludes to as he continues:

No, in all these things we are more than conquerors through him who loved us. (Romans 8:37)

It is not that we are the ones who conquered.  It is Christ who did the fighting.  We are merely the refugees who He rescued.  Our eternal hope rests in Christ saving us from the stain of sin.  He never promised that we'd be saved from our suffering now.  In fact, we are told we are being punished, disciplined, by our Father for our sins.  But it is temporary.

As Christ said:

"I have said these things to you, that in me you may have peace. In the world you will have tribulation. But take heart; I have overcome the world.”  (John 16:33)



If you stuck with me this long, are still reading and haven't thrown your computer through a plate-glass window, you deserve a Kit-Kat.  If you still think "tl dr" I'm sorry.  I could have gone longer, but that would have included a three or more page tangent on how the Fall is to blame for weather.

If you want to help, you can go to Lutheran World Relief (here) or Orphan Grain Train (here) for ways to do so.

Wednesday, September 6, 2017

No Taking It Back Now (or) That Envelope Was Heavy

Well.  That's done.  I mailed of my response to the acceptance email from Ft. Wayne.  I'll soon know when classes officially start for me, and when I'll be able to take the entrance exams.

In the mean time, Greek and Hebrew studying for me.  (yay)

And playing in my spare time with a novel that went from maybe one book to three.  Spare time?  What spare time?  Between work, two active boys, one rambunctious girl, one kiddo to arrive, financial aid searching, I really don't have spare time.

So why am I here writing when I should be working on stuff?  Pardon me while I make a hasty if melodramatic exit with the equally over-the-top "I shall return!"

Saturday, September 2, 2017

Countdown, And Not To The New Star Wars (or) Incoming: Panic Because There's No Time To Panic!

Its like I upgraded from a hard-served R2 astromech to a slick R6.  Not quite those new-fangled R7s, R8s, and R9s, but still quite the step up from where I was.

Don't worry if that doesn't make any sense.

What should make sense, and is much more important is news I got about a week ago.  Well, I guess the "new droid" does make this news easier to handle, since I'll be needing it.

I've been trying to get into seminary for a long time now.  After having the process of applying to St. Louis keep getting snagged I applied to Ft. Wayne.  The logic was simple: two applications makes it twice as likely that I get accepted.  Now, perhaps its a near decade of experience, or it may be a simpler admission department, but the results are undeniable.

Concordia Theological Seminary Ft. Wayne has accepted my application.

This is great news!  Quick!  Call up the minstrels so we can celebrate properly!  (Oh, wait, can't do that.  The minstrels were eaten during the winter of the quest for the grail.)

The complicating news is that St. Louis will be reviewing my application in two weeks, on Sept. 11.  Which leads to the trouble I have.  You see, I want to simply fill out the paperwork saying I will be attending, pack up my family, and move in about nine months.

But what to do with St. Louis?  Just not sure how to word it to them.  Because I've worked for a long time trying to apply to there, and they've done a lot to help.  That, and there's a part in the back of my mind that protests, saying I'm giving up... somehow.  Which is a bit ridiculous, because either way I reached my goal.  Just apparently I was looking in the wrong state.

So now that I've got a large chunk of work done, I have more work to do.  I have to complete the tests, study the languages, apply for financial aid, and contact churches who may be willing to "adopt" me and my family.

Which will be very helpful, since we'll also be needing diaper money.

Yep, that's right.  Kiddo No. 4.

So we're in a bit of a countdown situation with regards to 1) moving, 2) classes starting, and 3) new baby.

Like the toys pondered: should we be hysterical?!?  (flail arms)

No!  Yes!  Maybe... but not right now!

Monday, March 6, 2017

Is "borrowing" from pirates still piracy? (or) Why the Shack is actually a Lean-To

Yep, I have no shame.  I'm stealing ("borrowed, borrowed with intention to credit") from Pirate Christian Radio.  If you're not listening to their shows, you should be.

Anyway.  Pr. Rosebrough has an article in the Log about the most recent attempt at evangelical Christianity to make a movie.  Thought the article was good, so I'll just post the link here.

The Shack movie bombs as evangelism tool.

Happy Monday, and if you're looking for a movie, try the latest Batman.  8 out of 10 Michael Keatons and 9 out of 10 Val Kilmers agree this Batman is the best Batman.

Monday, February 27, 2017

Yeah, I don't have a clever title for this one.

I don't know why I keep saying I'll keep up with writing on this blog.  I just don't have the discipline, nor the time.

Oh, no, I'm not quitting.  At least not quitting the writing part.  Just promising to be timely.  That I won't be continuing.  Meh...

Anyway.  Admission meeting is two weeks from today (*), so those of you who are invested in that part of this, prayers are appreciated.  There really shouldn't be anything left for them to say no to, but I've been told that before.  We'll soon see.  In the meantime, I've got tests to study for (hoping to get all of Greek's active verb paradigm memorized by Friday, then I'll work on the Hebrew verb).

In other news... most recent kiddo is one.  Tenth wedding anniversary is forthcoming.  Trip to the capital (national, not state) in April.  Yep, 2017's busy.  And that's not bad, necessarily.

Been working on a number of ideas for stories, including a few new ones.  Found a radio station (out of an LCMS church, no less) that has a segment playing soundtrack music.  Happy day.  They even take short stories to read along with the music, and I've brainstormed a few ideas.  If I ever actually write them, I'll toss them up here.

Until then...

*(Yeah, that didn't happen.  They bumped my application review back to Oct., then moved it up to Sept.  Getting very tired of being yanked about.)