Wednesday, October 11, 2017

Would He Walk 500 Miles, Then 500 More, Just To Be A Hero? (or) This Feels Like Deja Vu, Or Deja Vu Of Deja Vu

So, everyone is still talking about how "The Force Awakens" was just a remake/reboot of "A New Hope," and how it looks like the sequel will be a carbon-copy of the original sequel.

But is it?

And if it is, is that bad?

And if it isn't, is that good?

No, no/kinda, maybe.

I will start with the second question.  "Is that bad (that TLJ is a remake/reboot of ESB)?"  No.  Or kinda.  Or both.  How can it be both?  Mythology.

If you look about at the classic myths (Greece, Rome, Norse, etc) you will see similar stories, heroic types, monsters, and themes.  Joseph Campbell, who studied mythologies, noticed these common items and wrote a book about it: The Hero With A Thousand Faces.  In it he describes the "monomyth" (sometimes also called "the hero's journey").  Not all "saga-type" stories adhere to all the parts, and not all follow in the prescribed order, but stories that feature these archetypes tend to feel big and epic.  Campell's work influenced a number of storytellers.

Including an innovative film maker in the 1970s with a story he called "Star Wars."

While wiki may be be a "better" way to learn about this, the TV Tropes site has a good article too.  (Right here -> The Hero's Journey)  There are seventeen steps.

The gist is this:
  • Act 1 - Departure - the hero leaves the familiar world behind
  • Act 2 - Initiation - the hero learns to navigate the unfamiliar world of adventure
  • Act 3 - Return - the hero returns to the familiar world

I could sum these three up with quotes from the original Star Wars trilogy.
"You must learn about the Force, if you are to come with me to Alderaan."
"There you will learn from Yoda, the Jedi master who instructed me."
"No more training, do you require. Already know you that which you need."
The original trilogy follows Luke, and his plot adheres to the Monomyth cycle quite nicely.  You want examples?  Very well.

Miraculous or circumstances surrounding hero's conception/birth:  He's a twin.  (Granted, we don't know this initially, but his being an orphan counts sort of as half point here.)

A herald brings The Call to adventure: R2 and the message from the princess.  This leads directly to...

Refusing The Call: its not that he likes the Empire, but there's nothing he can do about it.

Crossing the first threshold: Could be the destruction of the homestead, or the flight from Tatooine.  Either way, its a rapid and violent break from the "safe" place he was in.

There are many more categories, and even subcategories.  They aren't needed for a good story, but many good stories do have some aspects of the cycle.

Now I fully believe that the guys and gals at Lucasfilm are on the right track emulating the original trilogy.  Why?  'Cause it works.  And since they are operating out of the monomyth cycle playbook, and in the Star Wars universe to boot, things will look very similar.  Hence the answer to my third question, "is that good," because it might be.

Now, I think it is, and am willing to give them the benefit of the doubt (for now).  But, let's see if they really are adhering to the cycle.  Let's examine if the main character is on the Hero's Journey, based only on TFA.
  • The Call to Adventure - BB-8 shows up on Jakku and needs help from Rey.  At Niima Outpost they run into Finn.
  • Refusal of the Call - Rey is hesitant to assist BB-8, and especially unhappy to work with Finn (initially).  After hijacking the Falcon she wants to go back to Jakku.
  • Supernatural Aid - BB-8, Finn, Han Solo, Maz Kanata all could count.  The Force, most obviously.
  • Crossing the First Threshold - Hijacking the Falcon during the attack.
  • Belly of the Whale - The vision with the Skywalker Lightsaber.  The torture Rey endured from Kylo Ren, including her ability to turn it around.  Somewhat literally would be the Falcon being taken aboard Han and Chewie's new ship, and the subsequent "adventure" with rathtars.
  • The Road of Trials - Rey first "tapping" into her powers, but reverse-interrogating Kylo Ren.
  • Meeting with the Goddess/Love - Both Finn and Han showing her that they care.  In the former regarding her safety.  With the latter regarding offering her a job.  Both willingly go to save her.
  • Temptation - The desire to return to Jakku is one, but so is Kylo Ren's offer to train Rey.
  • Atonement with the Hero’s Father - Rey hasn't experienced this yet, I think.
  • Peace and Fulfillment Before the Hero’s Return - Rey coming to accept that whoever she's been waiting for on Jakku won't be back.
  • The Ultimate Boon - If the lightsaber fight didn't prove she's gonna be a Jedi...
  • Refusal of the Return - She doesn't go back to Jakku, but travels to Ahch-To to train with Luke.
  • Magic Flight - Escaping from the cell using a Jedi mind trick.
  • Rescue from Without - The Falcon showing up to rescue Rey and Finn after the lightsaber fight.
  • Return - Viewing the map at the Resistance base.
  • Master of Two Worlds - Not yet.
  • Freedom to Live - Moving forward after losing her home, her father figure, and almost losing her best friend.

Now, this is just me, being a nerd.  It isn't official, and I may be wrong, but since I see the similarities, especially in the storytelling methods, as strengths, it makes the story more enjoyable.  That's one advantage of writing fiction.  I have grown a greater appreciation for the craft, the art, the science of storytelling.

So, no, The Last Jedi isn't a "remake/reboot" of The Empire Strikes Back.  There will be many similarities, in part because it has been a considerable time since the originals came out.  And since the First Order is the heir of the Empire, it makes sense they'd use similar but improved methods and weapons.  To complain about the "Death Star 3" and such would be like complaining that a movie on tanks in Desert Storm was just a ripoff of a movie on the Battle of the Bulge because the tanks are obviously just "bigger" versions of the old ones, used in basically the same way.

Sounds silly because it is.

Besides, at the end of the day, if you're still feeling salty about it, just repeat the Mystery Science Theater 3000 mantra:

Until Dec. 15, remember to keep calm and carry on, and enjoy an ice cold Fanta... on me, of course.

Tuesday, October 10, 2017

Not A Fan Of Bait-And-Switch (or) I Have A Bad Feeling About This

So, the trailer for The Last Jedi (a.k.a.: Episode VII) dropped last night.  If you have been living off the grid and/or protest the NFL so hard you didn't dare watch it during "haph-thyme" here it be.

(Caution: Proper safety measures should be employed before watching.  Failure to take appropriate precautions could result injuries including, but not limited to: bruising on chin from jaw drop, electrical shock from short circuiting computer during spit-take, and concussion from rapid and repeated application of face palm maneuver.  The faculty and staff of "In The Loop" blog is not responsible for any and all injuries sustained during consumption of postings.)


Before I do anything else, two points must be made.

1) For the record, I don't like having a sports entity using the popularity of Star War to attempt to gain viewership.  I know, I know, this was planned before the most recent downturn in professional handegg viewership, but the point still stands.

2) There will be many theories, regarding all scenarios and characters, but I must make a clear statement before I dive head first into the rabbit hole:


That's not to say I don't have a Snoke theory (or theories), or have read a few I think are pretty good.  But I'll stand by the "official" statement.

First, what we can be sure (or at least decently sure) of.  Luke is hesitant to train Rey, who is seriously talented.  Snoke saw something more than just power in Kylo/Ben.  The Resistance and the First Order have more equipment that before.  For the former that might include the remains of the Republic fleet.

Now, allow me to put on my tin-foil hat.

All of Luke's lines in the trailer are directed at Rey.  All of Rey's lines are directed at Luke.

So far, fan theory seems to point to Rey asking Kylo Ren at the end to train her.  I don't believe so.  Why?  Her clothes don't appear to be the gray colored ones, but the lighter ones she's seen training in on Ahch-To.  My theory: Rey asks for him to show her where she belongs.  Luke has a vision of the destruction of the academy (the fire with him next to R2, him crawling out of rubble).  He agrees to train her, only to find how much potential she has.  She presses, which leads to a more "intense" training, akin to Dagobah.  This is supported by her in the pool and Luke on shore, soaked, saying it "this is not going to go the way you think."  My guess is she lashed out at his methods.

I think that, despite having reached whatever "dark" goal he had previously, Kylo/Ben will be closer to rejecting the Dark Side than last time.  Notice, he smashes his helmet.  Not in a "tantrum" way, like when he redecorated the interrogation room.  It seems more in a "I hate this" way.  His apparent hesitation to fire on the bridge of the Resistance ship supports this, as well as talking about being rid of the past.  If Leia dies here, I'm guessing it isn't Kylo/Ben who pulls the trigger.

At some point Team Good Guys will be on a planet with crystals (note the Falcon flying through what looks like a geode tunnel full of red, kybur?, crystals).  Material for new big guns?

Star War's fan wiki claims that the Resistance evacuates their base from the first film.  Similar to Ep. V, but how similar remains to be seen.  But they're also on some sort of desert-like planet, which according to the wiki is home to the Resistance base.  So, two attacks on Resistance bases in one movie.  And unless Leia escapes the space battle (which I'm assuming is concurrent with the evac) there's little chance he fired on the bridge of that ship, since Leia is standing on that arid planet with the weird red dust.

It also claims Finn is part of an operation that infiltrates the First Order.  Why?  I bet in part to rescue Rey.  That's what leads to him fighting with Phasma.  And why we see Kylo/Ben standing with something burning behind him.  He's there during the major fight at the end.

Lastly, somewhere along the line Rey gets captured again by the First Order or is part of infiltration mission.  She ends up squaring off with Snoke, who taunts, torments, and tortures her.

Things unanswered: Who is Snoke?  Who is Rey?  Who is Finn?  What are those books?  What is a porg?  Will DAR ever get his Fanta?

(Am I the only one who wants to see Luke purposelessly punt a precocious pseudo-penguin?)

We won't know any of these things (including how off base I likely am) until December 15th.  Until then, may the Force be with you.

And also with you.

Monday, October 9, 2017

Great Scott! (or) Not Feeling It Today, So Enjoy This Random Discussion Starter

So, yeah, after a week of daily posts about vocation et al, I've got nothing truly worth posting (or at least not ready).

What I do have is a random discussion from last week at work.  Why?  Because we're all nostalgic millennials who occasionally discuss alternate history in such a way as to destroy the world.  Or conquer it.  As long as you remember to not invade Poland.  Or Russia when winter is coming.

What was I saying?

Right- our discussion of complete randomness.

If you could remake the Back To The Future movies, what car would you use to replace the DeLorean?

(Get in the time machine.  We'll explain earlier.)

Yep.  That's it.  We came up with a few, such as a Ford Model T, or the Toyota pickup Marty drives (it would be nigh indestructible).  What do you think?  Comment, or bug your friends, family, and coworkers with this pointless discussion.

Saturday, September 30, 2017

To Be Continued... (or) If This Works, I Could Upstage Indiana Jones

First off... a ridiculously huge thanks go out to Capt. Kirk and all the gang at KNNA.  Thank you for playing my story.  Hopefully I can have more of the story ready to air soon.

Second, and somewhat hilariously, I'm more upset at the Capt. mispronouncing Wagner than my name (long "au" sound).  A little curious what he used for music.  Oh well.

You can find the link to the show archive here, or just goes straight to the show itself here.  The story isn't read until the last half hour (if you want to skip ahead, its around the 93 minute mark, I think).

Let me know what you think.  Want to hear more?  Want the transcript posted here?  Know what music he used?  Comments and critiques welcomed.

Friday, September 29, 2017

Render Unto Gary Cooper What Is Alvin York's (or) Dual Loyalties Don't Necessarily Mutually Exclude [part V]

So, after four days of this, you are probably asking "why does the title say Gary Cooper and Alvin York?"  "I know Cooper was an actor, but who's York?"  "What does a 1930s Hollywood actor have to do with this?"

All good questions.  But first, let me ask you, do you know who Alvin York was?

(Big ears were so in style in 1918.  Epic 'staches a suggested option.)

If you get the chance, watch the 1941 movie "Sergeant York."  It does a good job of depicting the man's life.  It should, York was the guy who picked Gary Cooper (his favorite actor) to play him.  And, yes, he really did capture 132 Germans after having a duel with 30 machine guns.  By himself.  Captain America ain't got nothin' on York.

And while the historian in my could go on about a story like this, that's not the point this time.  Rather, I'm going to talk about how this former hellion turned pacifist was granted a Medal of Honor for killing 28 enemy and capturing 132.

Now, it has been a number of years since I watched the movie, but a few weeks ago it was on and I caught about 30 minutes of it during my lunch break.  I saw from his recruitment to the battle he became famous for.  His struggle, and answer, got me thinking about vocation.

What is vocation?

Simply put, a "vocation" is a task or duty for someone to complete.  Currently, my primary vocations include "husband," "father," "child," "sibling," and "employee."  Soon "student" will be added to the list, and after that "pastor."

Some of these duties overlap, such as husband and father.  Rarely are they mutually exclusive.  And a vocation does not have to be "religious."  I heard Luther once quoted as saying a mother changing diapers (which is part of the vocation of parent) is more "spiritual" than a monk saying vespers.

So, back to York.  He had chosen to be a pacifist, which is not required of the vocation of Christian, but his rational is completely understandable (since he converted, gave up alcohol, and went pacifist after a friend died in a duel).  However, the government chose him to become a soldier.  Within the vocation of soldier, being violent in controlled instances is the core task.

The movie depicts him in training, doing admirably.  The city kids who were recruited made fun of his accent (Tennessee) and simplistic yet direct thinking.  The instructors did too.  Until they handed him a rifle.  Most recruits had no idea how to shoot a gun.  York grew up with a muzzleloader he used to hunt with.  Hitting a bed sheet fifty yards away was too easy for him.  His skill with a gun was part of why he was promoted to corporal.

That's when he became more vocal about his desire not to kill.  His sergeant, his commanding officer, and the officer in charge of the entire unit, all spoke with him, and did so rationally, not just "you'll follow orders!" you would have expected.

Where it comes to a head is when he's given some leave before, likely, shipping out.  He is encouraged to go home and consider what to do.  While discussing if it is right for a Christian to fight in a war, he and the officers trade quotes from Scripture, and correctly, not just proof-texting.  The CO finally hands him a book on American history, specifically on the Founding Fathers, encouraging York to read it and consider.  He does.

Finally, back home, sitting alone with this history book in one hand and the Bible in the other, Alvin York is at a loss.  What is he to do?  The Christian side of him says "don't fight."  The American side of him says "defend your nation."

Which is correct?

Opening his Bible, he turns to Matthew chapter 22.  Verse 21 provided the answer.
They [the Pharisees] said, "Caesar's."  Then He [Jesus] said to them, "Therefore render to Caesar the things that are Caesar's, and to God the things that are God's."
At that point, York realized that being a loyal Christian who sought to "do no harm" was not mutually exclusive with being a loyal citizen willing to go to war to defend the nation and those who are innocent.  If he had to kill, he would without seeking it on his own right, but if the opportunity never came up, then all the better.  Either way he would have done his duty, to God and country.

An antithesis to this, though still just as correct an understanding of the proper distinction between being a Christian and being a soldier, is Desmond Doss.  His story is told in the movie "Hacksaw Ridge," which tells the story of his service as an unarmed medic.  He elected to enter a combat zone unarmed, in a war against an enemy who would see no issue of killing a medic.  But his version of Christianity forbid him from carrying a weapon.  So he served during the invasion of Okinawa, some of the bloodiest fighting in all of human history.  And at no point did he draw blood.  Like York, he earned the Medal of Honor, and is the only unarmed conscientious objector to earn said medal.

So who is more correct in understanding vocation and the proper distinction of the Two Kingdoms, Alvin York or Desmond Doss?

Both.

Give to caesar what is caesar's, and to God what is God's.  We are to serve within our vocations both the State and the Church.  For the one in a position of authority in the State, executing their powers is appropriate and even Godly.  Yes, even killing an enemy soldier.

Now, this does not excuse war, nor do I mean to make the implication that war is God's desire.  Far from it.  But this is a sinful world, and conflict occurs.  And, like York discovered, being a soldier does not keep one from being a faithful Christian.

See, in the end this Two Kingdoms doctrine is easy, but intricate.  The teaching is simple, but there are many moving parts, and quickly we find ourselves in a theoretical discussion.  Not that this is a bad thing, but we cannot dwell here.  That was the mistake of the monastic movement.  Vocation and the Two Kingdoms and the Estates are, in a way, a call to "put your money where your mouth is" and see your life as Christian and [fill-in-the-blank] overlap.

And if any of this discourages you, just remember the one who never struggled with this.  His vocation of King and Servant were concurrent, as were His duties as both God and Man.  As a humble servant He was nailed to the Cross.  As the creator of the universe He rose from the dead.  Christ's two natures are not mutually exclusive, but are both active now.  If He is any less of one vocation or the other He is no longer the Christ.

Just like how the Triune God is simultaneously all Three Persons; distinct and authoritative in their duties, but united in their action.  You cannot have one without the other two.

Funny how all discussions of doctrine run back to Christology and the Trinity.  Almost like they actually matter.  Like that's all where supposed to focus on anyway...

Now, on to a new topic... once I find one.  Well... that's not true.  There's plenty, just not sure if the blog, as it is right now, it the most logical format.  I'll play with them and see what happens.  Until them....

Thursday, September 28, 2017

Render Unto Gary Cooper What Is Alvin York's (or) Dual Loyalties Don't Necessarily Mutually Exclude [part IV]

Now to talk about the Three Estates...

(Umm, not those three.  Those are estate cars.)

The State, the Family, and The Church.  Perhaps a picture to illustrate will help.

(Credit to Rev. Philip Hoppe, LCMS.  He put together a presentation on the Table of Duties which you can find heBlogre.  Plenty of good stuff available there.)


So, the infographic should be self-explanatory, but let's break it down a bit.

The bottom half is the "big picture" regarding God and the Church.  We, the Church, are under God's authority, and we obey and respect Him in all things.  We do this because we have been freed by His love and service.  Not necessarily reactionary, since it was not compulsory.

The top half breaks up the various authorities vested by God.  These are the Three Estates.

The Estate of the State is obvious, especially since I've already discussed it.  God has placed leaders in authority, and we as citizens are to obey and respect.  The State is armed with the Law, by which they maintain good order in civic society.

The Estate of the Church (as an organization on Earth) operates similarly.  There is a leader appointed (the pastor) who is in charge of running the group.  Not so much the "secular" side; that is, the pastor isn't called and ordained to be in charge of the upkeep of the lawn, or the picking of new carpet, or deciding if they should hire a new secretary.  Not that he shouldn't be part of those discussions, but issues such as those are technically part of the state.  The pastor leads the church regarding following the rules God has established for believers.  Remember, some laws are for all (don't murder, don't steal, etc), but some apply to the church (remember the Sabbath, etc).  The pastor is called to proclaim confession and absolution.  His weapon is not the Law, but the Gospel, which he preaches to the people so they might believe and be saved.

So, two out of three, pretty straight forward and easy to rightly divide.  The third, the Home, may seem a bit muddled.  The reason why is simple.  While the Estate of the State gets to only hold the sword of the Law, and the Estate of the Church can only grasp the sword of the Gospel, the Estate of the Home holds both because it is part of both.

(No matter what happens in my life, I fear I will never be as cool as Sir Christopher Lee dual wielding lightsabers while humming a symphonic metal song he wrote about Charlemagne.)*

But... wha... huh... didn't you say...?

Yep.  The State (as well as the Kingdom of the Left) does not use the Gospel.  And the Church (as well as the Kingdom of the Right) are not tasked with the Law.  Yet the Home gets to be both.

How?

Think of the Estate of the Home (or, as we could call it, the Family) as a bridge.  Like this one here:


On this side, we have the State - the Kingdom of the Left.
And the Estate of the State.

On this side, we find the Church - the Kingdom of the Right.
And the Estate of the Church.

And here in the middle is the Estate of the Home.

At times, the Home must use the Law (like when a child elects to hit his a sibling with a dog) and dole out punishment appropriate.  Other times, the Home uses Gospel (like when a child accidentally breaks mother's favorite knickknack) and establishes forgiveness.

Be aware, the Home is more than just the Parent-Child relationship, but also Husband-Wife, and Employer-Employee.  The Home covers the entirety of the Order of Creation, which God established in Eden.

Hence why the Estate of the Home is one of the most challenging, and at times most important.  (Not that the other two aren't important.)  The Home is where "the rubber meets the road" so to speak.  It is the practical side of this discussion.  It is the Ten Commandments and the Creeds in action.  In some ways it is a balancing act, having to determine when to use law and when to use gospel.  Each situation and scenario is different.  Part of why parenting is so difficult.

For example, I love my daughter, but if she climbs onto the dresser in the bedroom, I'm going to end up raising my voice, and possibly even disciplining her.  Out of anger?  No, out of love, and fear of her injuring herself.  Law, to be sure, but there is forgiveness too, once the lesson is made.  The gospel is without comfort if the sting of the law isn't felt.  That doesn't mean running about bashing people with the law just so we can give the gospel, but until someone comes to grips with their transgression, they will not be able to fully appreciate the grace given to them in the gospel.

(And, yes, my little girl has climbed on the dresser.  And, yes, she was instructed not to.)

But how about a more concrete example of the Two Kingdoms?  Maybe one found in a popular movie?  Perhaps finally I'll get around to exploiting the tease in the post title... tomorrow.


* Okay, so I don't actually know if he was humming a symphonic metal song about Charlemagne while on the set of Star Wars.  But I do know he actually sang a symphonic metal song about Charlemagne.  Actually, he produced four albums, and a number of other songs.  Yes, the White Wizard sang metal at age 90.  Seriously, its even on YouTube.

Wednesday, September 27, 2017

Render Unto Gary Cooper What Is Alvin York's (or) Dual Loyalties Don't Necessarily Mutually Exclude [part III]

By this point I've discussed the gist of the Two Kingdoms doctrine, and some examples in history to provide some background.  Now its time to examine the tools at their disposal.

The State uses the Law.

The Church uses the Gospel.

(Post is done.  Everyone go home.  Good game.)

Okay, so, maybe its a little more involved than that.  What is meant by Law and Gospel, in this context?  Lets start with the apparently more challenging one.


The Law is a very multi-faceted issue.  There are parts of it that were composed for a temporary use, while other parts have existed since before time, and a few from both categories are able to overlap, in a way.  An example, perhaps?

Killing has always been wrong.  But that statement is quite broad.  Killing anything?  Are there things we can kill?  And when?  Why?  From the "big picture" side, all forms of death are bad, this is a philosophical issue that runs consistent.  This objective truth is founded in the morality of the writer of the Law - God.  All other laws are extensions of this, influenced by the context of the Fall.

That is what makes the Law a challenge to nail down.  Is it wrong to kill?  Yes.  As a soldier who is sent to rescue POWs?  Well... no, quite the opposite, in context.  It is the vocation of the soldier to use force, even deadly force, but that does not mean he doesn't serve without sin, since he, like all of us, is sinful from birth.  Confession and absolution is still necessary.  Just because the context allows it temporally does not mean it is a "free play" existentially.

Now, ignore that cobweb riddled rabbit hole for a moment while I try to get back to the actual point.

The State's role is best summed up in Romans chapter 13.  It is the job of the State to compose rules for the safety, betterment, and even control of the earthly realm.  Things like speed limits, tax laws, building codes, TSA standards, sports regulations, website terms and conditions, etc.

This means it is not the State's job to forgive things.  If you break a law, you are due punishment.  This is appropriate.  The State is tasked with being an overlord.  It levies taxes, conducts war, and prosecutes criminals.  Is it possible for the State to go too far?  Of course.  But, as I've posted before, so long as the State is within God's established boundaries, we as Christians are to faithfully serve and follow all Biblically sound laws.  If the State exceeds its limits we are to seek out ways of bringing it back into those limits, preferably by legal means that do not require violence.

Now, for the actually challenging one.

The Church is tasked with forgiving sins, in the stead and by the command of Christ, who paid for all (ALL) transgressions.  The Church is not given the right to form rules for life now, though they are to adhere to the Law of God, summed up in the Commandments.  But the Church's primary, if not sole, role is to proclaim the Gospel.  If you are at a church that does not proclaim Christ crucified as the point of every sermon and worship service... well you're probably not at a Christian church.

And here we get to why this is the more difficult one for us.  With the State, there are rules, standards, codes by which to measure our actions by.  We can see progress and grasp how to be "better."  Its like a checklist, and we like checklists.  Being able to complete a task is very rewarding.  Even more so if it leads to something better.  That is something the Law claims to give us: a checklist of how to be a better person.  And we humans very much like that, especially us Americans.  Being able to self-justify and prove we are "worthy" is, for many of us, a driving goal in life.  But, in the grand scheme of salvation, it doesn't work this way.  The truth is completely logical and rational, yet it is exactly opposite to what we think should be "fair," and we simply can't wrap our minds around it.

What we cannot grasp is twofold.  One, the State (and by extension, the Law) cannot help us, in any way, to be a better (read: sanctified, justified) person.  Two, no matter how much we keep the Law, even if someone could be completely perfect regarding any and all aspects of the Law, our only reward ultimately is Hell.

"But if God established a law to be better, and it doesn't work that way, how do we get to heaven?"

We don't get to heaven.  We don't do anything.  We are the lifeless person drowning in the pool.  What can the drowning, unconscious man do to save himself?

The Gospel is rescue, that we are powerless to participate in.  We are passive, receiving Grace that we have neither earned nor deserved.  We deserve Hell.  Thanks be to God that Christ came and saved us from sin, death, and our own self-serving nature.

That is the Church's duty.  To proclaim the Cross and the Empty Tomb.  To give us the knowledge that we are not hopeless, but saved, which frees us to be able to attempt to adhere to the law.  We'll fail, but we are forgiven.

But where does Law and Gospel come to action?  That is what the Three Estates is all about.  Until next time...